Project 1
-In project 1 I did a good job quoting text from the book and from articles I found online. This is the first time I have ever added a synthesis into a paper.
Project 3 Peer Review
-I think that my peer response is shown here as much better than my first peer review. I made more changes and corrections to my peers paper rather than just grammar mistakes which was completely different than my first peer review
Blog Post 15 Brandt
-This blog post was definitely my best blog. I used quotes, and examples from the book. I could tell by reading this that i started getting the hang of reading scholarly journals.
Thursday, November 29, 2012
Sunday, November 18, 2012
Blog Post 32
Citation
Alexander, Jonathan. “Transgender Rhetorics: (Re)Composing
Narratives of the Gendered Body.”
I. Summary
In Jonathan Alexander’s article, “Transgender Rhetorics:
(Re) Composing Narratives of the Gendered Body”, he talks all about how gender
is a very questionable topic. He talks about the components of what makes
man and women so very different. He then goes on to talk about of a friend of
his that had a sex change from woman to man. She turned into a man and
changed her name to Patrick Cailifia-Rice to better fit her new appearance.
How can we know he is a man, is the question Alexander asks. His students
accepted him as a man but how do when really call him a man? Alexander
also talks about how gender is influenced in the classroom and what role it
plays in teachings. When given a place to openly express their feelings,
students feel more confidant in the classroom. Having a good understanding
of gender identities in the classroom can help everyone be more accepting and
functional in the world outside of the classroom environment.
II. Dialectical
Notebook
|
In
this column you RESPOND to the quotes
|
In
this column you TYPE OUT the quote
|
|
This quote is trying to show that participation helps those
that don’t understand the transgender community to get a better understanding
of their behavior. Society is meant to be a certain way, and when someone
crosses over or does something different than the societies norm it is
frowned upon. But we have to learn about other that are different than us to
really have an understanding of todays society.
|
"I
want to argue than trans theorists and pedagogical activities inspired by
them can remind us to complement our understanding of gender performance with
a sense of gender as a material and embodied reality".
|
|
This quote is important because it explains the fact that
sexuality clashes or collides with our understanding of gender. Gender is
either being a man or a female, and sexuality meaning being attracted to
either males or females. This completely collides with our understanding of
gender.
|
"Most recently, composition scholarship in this vein has
grappled with issues not only of gender but also of sexuality, recognizing
that sexuality intersects with and complicates our understanding of
gender".
|
|
This
article and quote relate to Delpit. This talks a lot about not fitting in
because of of sexual orientation because the standards the society has placed
upon people who are different. Much like people who are black have a
different dialect, it is frowned upon to not speak white English.
|
“Our students’ identities, informed by prevailing, politicized
and personal definitions of gender and sexuality, can have a significant
impact on their participation in class, their sense of themselves as
learners.”
|
|
This quote is about questioning the queer theory. I can
see how people can have different identities and that they are not accepted
for these ideas.
|
“Queer theory can be used to highlight for all students how
our identities are shaped and communicated through a variety of intersecting
social processes.”
|
|
This quote
is important because Alexander talks about the importance of teachers opening
up their classrooms to not only empower and encourage their students to talk
about their own thoughts and experiences, but to open the minds of all the
students in the classroom to take a look at the personal and political
oppression put on by society. Personal, meaning a sense of sexuality, and
political meaning the sociocultural expectations put up by society, intersect
and collide. The goal in the classroom is to give a better understanding of
all students about this process and what is felt about this process.
|
"Opening
up spaces in our classrooms to allow and encourage students to undertake such
explorations not only empowers them and promotes their own agency but also
potentially extended critical awareness to all students of how writing can be
used to explore the intersection between the seemingly personal and the
political".
|
|
This quote is talking about how we should see gender as more
then a rhetoric. It is a way of identification. Gender is used
more as a identification then we know. It is everywhere. And when
we can’t tell if a guy is a guy or if a girl is a girl, things get very
awkward. It must be very hard for people like that.
|
“And pedagogically, considering with students gender beyond
its rhetorical dimensions is not to leave rhetoric behind, but to think about
rhetoric in a more materially grounded way.”
|
Thursday, November 15, 2012
Blog Post 31
I. Summary
Lisa Delpit’s article, “The Politics of Teaching Literate
Discourse”, is all about the different types of discourse, mainly primary and
secondary discourse. This article of is mainly to disprove James Paul
Gee’s theory on primary and secondary and his ideas of being involved in a discourse
community. It talks about planning on
not getting in a discourse community if you are already in a DC because you
will have many problems change discourses in the future. She gives many
examples of black people that did not have a primary DC that were successful in
life. She says that these people would not have had the opportunities
they had if the teachers had Gee’s mind set about discourse communities.
II. Dialectic
Notebook
|
In
this column you RESPOND to the quotes
|
In
this column you TYPE OUT the quote
|
|
This quote relates to Gee’s article in many ways.
The first discourse we learn is the most influential discourse in our lives.
It always says that switching communities can be difficult.
|
"Gee maintains that there are primary discourse, those
learned in the home, and secondary discourses, which are attached to
institutions or groups one might later encounter".
|
|
This quote introduces Delpit’s main argument against Gee. Once
you are in a discourse community is very hard to get into another discourse
community without complicating terms with the other discourse community. The
individual is born into a discourse community, and changing is a difficult
thing to do.
|
"The status of individuals born into a particular
discourse tends to be maintained because primary discourses are related to
secondary discourses of similar status in our society".
|
|
Delpit gives advice to what teachers should do to students who
have a different home discourse and literacy. She says that if they are
not well educated about this than they will not be successful in college.
|
"First, teachers must acknowledge and validate students'
home language without using it to limit students' potential"
|
|
This quote is important in it demonstrates Delpits claims. She
talks about a man named Clarence Cunningham was a very good football player
in high school but only had a C average. The teachers seeing his
potential made him work harder on his schoolwork or else he was not allowed
to play football anymore. The teachers were his biggest influence.
|
“Clarence Cunningham, now a vice chancellor at the largest
historically black institution in the United States, grew up in a painfully poor
community in rural Illinois”
|
|
This quote really shows what teachers should do for students
that come from backgrounds that are not as great as other students.
Delpit then says that teachers can discuss openly the injustices of allowing
certain people to succeed based not a talent but what your last name
is. This quote was very propionate around the time college applying
began. You already who was getting what before the even applied.
|
“A final role that teachers can take is to acknowledge the
unfair “discourse-stacking” that our society engages in.”
|
|
Delpit is wanting to fight the oppressed people and get them
the an education that everyone should get. This quote really shows that
people should change so that people of a poor background can have the same
opportunities as a person that is rich.
|
“Individuals can learn the “superficial features” of dominant
discourses, as well as their more subtle aspects.”
|
.
Blog Post 30
In Geneva Smithermans’ article, “‘God Don’t Never
Change,’” she explains how students are taught to use grammar in the classroom.
She provides three different groups of language usage. The first group of
language she explains is white English (WE), the second is blacks using both
their dialect and WE (which is referred to as bidialectal, or BD), and the
third is standard Black English (BE or BI). In reading this article I was
asking myself what each language group meant. Then I started thinking that
language really has “changed” it has just been formed into the way it is now
throughout the course of the years. This thought came to me because she talks
about how Americans were colonized by the British and learned language from
them, and blacks learned their language from the whites who enslaved them. It
was very interesting to see how language and grammar has been shaped by
different cultures and different circumstances. Every culture has a different
language and grammar history depending on the circumstances their language was
started upon.
Peer Response
The peer response I received was very helpful. She pointed out a lot of
grammar mistakes I made that I previously would never have noticed. I think
that kept both the positives from my paper and the mistakes and pointed out
both which is very important. I now see that I need to be more aware of my grammar
and the mistakes that I frequently make when writing papers. My peer response
partner sent everything to me on time and made things extremely easy for me.
She was a big help and I think that my paper will be much better because of
they help she provided. Peer review is extremely important when writing a paper
because you as the writer cannot always see the mistakes you make when writing
a paper. So having a peer help with this process is a not only a large help,
but its also very important part of the writing process.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)